You can also talk to other gun owners to get their opinion on the matter. JavaScript is disabled. Both are light and feel great. mazzgolf Only the more "sophisticated" hunters bothered with 1-1/2 ounce 2-3/4 inch magnums for geese or turkey. The Browning Maxus isgas-driven- I'm looking to get an inertia gun. POLL: when was the last time you went to a drive-in movie? Affinity 3 Turkey Elite . Affinity 3.5. It fits me okay and overall I have no real complaints, but I'm not as in love with it as I thought I would be. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. After researching and reading numerous incredibly positive reviews by gun "experts", I purchased a Grey Hunter. I am not going to pay Benelli's prices when there are less expensive guns that are just as reliable. It may not display this or other websites correctly. Nor did most folks obsess over ribs and beads, as a raised/ventilated rib was deemed unnecessary for hunting purposes. Benelli has recoil spring in the stock, not under the forearm. Designed for a more natural feel, the Franchi Affinity 3 12 Gauge Shotgun delivers consistent performance with enhanced maneuverability for a more successful day in the field or at the trap range. A big part of my decision was how it looked and pointed for me. I have a super Vinci for waterfowl, but picked up a Merkel 201 to use for clays and upland hunting. The new A5 "kinematic action" in 12 gauge remains a hard gun to love. Should be plenty of posts on it use the search feature. Franchi's Affinity 3 uses an inertia-driven operating system that weighs less, has fewer moving parts and runs cleaner than gas-powered shotguns. Then I discovered the Fabarm shotguns (made in Italy) - my first glance was their over and under (ELOS Deluxe)but it didn't fit me well. . A pump action or semi-automatic shotgun would be a better choice. Why this minor change is called a redesign is anyone's guess, but the several Affinity models I've tested have been solid performers. The franchi is nice, but it is not a benelli. I beat the absolute crap out of it duck, pheasant and grouse hunting and I have never had an issue. A little over 600 shells through the affinity and I love it so far. The answer is yes, and no. Franchi 12 gauge: Except Sporting SL O/U, Highlander, I-12 Sporting and Affinity current production with trapezoidal threads: interchanges with Trulock's Beretta/Benelli style. I think Franchi are made in the Stoeger factory, Stoeger are made in the Benelli factory, Benelli are made in the Beretta factory, and Beretta are made in the Franchi factory :biggrin: I've owned two Affinity's, 12 and a 20. Guess I could add that I've shot a Montefeltro 20 since the '90s, and think the world of them. The Benelli brand has several solid inertia guns that are very well known. Back in 2012, Phil from Field & Stream commented on the then newly released Fabarm USA XLR5, saying, "I have not cleaned the gun yet (this is known as testing, not laziness) and after about 600 rounds it started having trouble with my slow 11/16 ounce reloads. The affinity actually fits me a little better, I think due to the raise rib on the barrel. benelli montefeltro Browning cyynergy field Beretta a400 . My experience thus far has been great and it should be on your "must see" list before you settle for something elseI'm glad I did. I am a lefty so that is making me lean towards the Monte. "Of the many dozens of 20 gauge repeaters I've tested and owned, none of them are as remotely as hard on your thumb as the Benelli M2 and now, the Franchi Affinity. F. fadetoblack188 New member. So I spent the winter testing it on clays. Don't know pecans about lefties and right handed guns, but do know lefties are the only ones ever expressing a need to be on a certain end of the blind. Benellis shotguns are used by many different law enforcement agencies and militaries around the globe. They can't be wrong. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Never an issue.. "All men die, not all men really live". Are Franchi's made in the Benelli factory or are Benelli's made in the Franchi factory? Have shot a number of different one's but none was in the same class as that old Browning! Man, when you sky blasting you need all the help you can get. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. The walnut versions are great looking guns, as befits a Weatherby. Never hear a righty say, "I'm right handed, so I need to be". . I use it a lot for clays and upland hunting . It shoulder well and Ive patterned waterfowl loads and XRs out of it and it shoots great! If you want to save some money get the Franchi. There are no short-recoil shotguns of any consequence in production. If you are simply looking for a good, reliable shotgun that will get the job done, then a Benelli might be a good option for you. Apr 28, 2019 #3 BriarPatch99 Senior Member Franchi is owned by Beretta (Holdings) .. Franchi is imported by Benelli USA .. If you had an A-5 in an autoloader or a Winchester Model 12 ("The Perfect Repeater") in a slide action, you were good. May 15, 2021 #34 I am so on the fence! Duck Dynasty uses Benneli. Affinity 3.5 Waterfowl Elite. None of them were commercially successful. Affinity 3. FRANCHI AFFINITY 3 VS BENELLI M2 SERIES. Go with Uncle Sy. Newsletter Sign-Up. Have you thought of going to a 20 ga? Many people who own them report being happy with their purchase. I busted some clays today with the bro-law and nephew. The classic Auto-Five would be very costly to produce today and we do not like making adjustments to autoloaders based on load intensity. Barnum stands for Tactical. Almost negligent if I'm being honest, but it keeps going and going. Retay vs Benelli vs Franchi 20 or 12 gau To me, the affinity and M2 are nearly the same guns and feel the same. LimbSaver Classic Precision Recoil Pad, Benelli 12ga. Didnt read any of the other posts but for easy uplandfield type hunting, get a nice beretta over under in 20ga. I have had 1 failure to feed and that was with a 1oz load. I looked at the Montefeltro and Ultralight and both look and feel awesome. For those who get worn out with the funny colored receivers, Cole Gunsmithing can anodize your A400 receiver into a strikingly good looking gun. Powered by Invision Community, NJDFW 2021-2022 New Jersey Hunting and Trapping Digest, https://www.benelli.it/en/arma/super-black-eagle-3-wood. Cant go wrong with monte for the money. (Nor do many shooters like the "double shuffle" recoil of the A-5, which actually increases the felt recoil. Is there a difference significant enough to validate almost double the cost? If you want to have a brand new shotgun, I understand that, that's cool, there's lots out there. Yea look into it. Softest and most reliable gas auto I have ever owned, and I have owned them all. They also have a wide variety of resources available on their websites, including FAQs, manuals, and instructional videos. I love it. It is the best working man's autoloader Remington has ever created and it is a very good gun. Franchi Affinity 3 Upland What Gauge to get? Gonna call Franchi tomorrow. Ultimately, benelli (the company) isn't going to mind if you purchase the benelli or franchi as they are all owned by the same company, beretta. Never had an issue with mine. In addition to shotguns, they also make rifles and pistols. Now, Ive shot the Berretta and its an awesome gun. In 20 gauge, the six pound Weatherby SA-08 and Benelli M2 Comfortech are tough guns, but not at all tough to carry. This operating system dominates centerfire autoloading handguns and was the system used by the famous Maxim machine gun, but it has never sold well when applied to shotguns. Copyright 2016 by Randy Wakeman. You must log in or register to reply here. The montefeltro has a flat rib, the Franchi has a raised rib more like the SBE2. With the recoil spring being under the forearm of the Franchi, it's a little wider but still very slim feeling. The Franchi looks to have alot of the same qualities as the Benelli M2 except for the price and chamber size. Put handguns head to head to compare size, weight, capacity, and more Description. In the United States, the L4S marks Fabarm's first venture into the lightweight hunting gun field, and the XLR5 Waterfowler is coming out soon. Is the Monte worth an extra few hundred bucks? Anyone know what the difference is between the franchi affinity and the Benelli montefltro? JavaScript is disabled. Not being a contrarian, but looking at these two guns, theyre identical. Ask a buddy which inertia-action semi-auto to buy and chances are they'll recommend a Benelli. I've decided I want an inertia gun this time. In fact, they are one of the most well-known shotgun manufacturers in the world. Affinity 3 Waterfowl Elite . But if I had to buy another tomorrow, it would most likely be a Franchi. Still, this can be rectified if necessary. As far as my own preference, in a 12 gauge it would be the Fabarm USA L4S as an upland gun and the Remington V3 as a plain-Jane looking, but do everything type of autoloader. You are using an out of date browser. I've been told that I'm "all thumbs" so it is difficult to know exactly what to measure. All rights reserved. I have tested several and they are good, solid, reliable autoloaders with better than average triggers and a good warranty. Our Sitemap. Though the Benelli brand and associated Beretta family brands have tried, they have not caught on as clays guns, due to heavier recoil than gas guns. In this article, we will take a closer look at both brands and compare them head-to-head. Affinity 3.5 Turkey Elite . I have a Beretta A300 which fits into the midrange price-wise. Nevertheless, the Vinci rates as a good gun, if you don't mind its peculiarities and somewhat alarming aesthetics. Our sample gun was a 28"-barreled 12 gauge . I carry a 20 gauge montefeltro because it's very light weight . Salesman was saying benelli has a chrome lined chamber vs non on the franchi. It kicks less and is heavier (Im pretty sure on the heavier, but not certain). The company is headquartered in Urbino, Italy. It wasn't that tough, for a 2-3/4 inch chamber was all that was needed or wanted, lead was shot at everything and something like a Browning A-5 Light Twelve 12 gauge bored modified choke did it all. Snipers Hide is a community of Snipers of all kinds, focusing on long range shooting, accuracy, and ballistics. JavaScript is disabled. Also if you look at the montefeltro notice the vent rib is lower on that gun than the others mentioned,it might not fit as well as say a m2 benelli. I have recoil sensitivity issues..pretty serious actually. Sure, folks wanted ribs on their Model 12s for trapshooting, but there wasn't much debate about the "good autoloader" or the "good shotgun" back then. By The Remington 1100 still has a strong following, but its action does not compensate as well for load intensity as some other actions and the 1100 is the last mainstream autoloader to have a machined steel receiver. Full Member. The franchi is a clone to the benelli m2 field. Some claim recoil doesn't matter, but with all the miracle recoil pads, springy stock things, and managed-recoil shotshells out there, to many people how soft a shotgun shoots remains very important. Come join the discussion about safety, gear, tips, tricks, optics, hunting, gunsmithing, reviews, reports, accessories, classifieds, and more! I have the affinity 3.5. I laughed out loud, for 11/16 ounce of shot is a .410 bore load or a substandard 28 gauge load. While this approach can work for a good long while for long recoil and some kinematic / inertia guns, it is not the best approach with gas actions. It may not display this or other websites correctly. The quality is great. Last year I handled multiple versions of the benelli and beretta 20 gauge autos and I went with the Montefeltro. Gas actions handle the widest variety of loads and, for a given weight of gun, have the softest recoil. Benelli Montefeltro VS Franchi Affinity. I currently have a 12 ga. SX3 which works great just a tad heavy. The direct acting shotguns with the Benelli system kick like a mule. I have no experience with the other two you're considering, but have had my share of shotguns throughout the years. The only Benelli I care for is the Montefeltro. Franchi is an Italian company that has been making high-quality shotguns for over a hundred years. You'll love the affinity. JavaScript is disabled. by pacecars April 10th, 2021, 8:18 pm, Post Benelli Ethos or Montefeltro by Hotchkiss Fri Feb 13, 2015 2:43 am Well I went to get an Ethos with 26 inch barrell and picked up the Montefeltro. I sold both and went back to Beretta Extrema II whichhas never had a cycling issue. I can't say anything bad about my versamax. inertia 20ga autos aren't made to shoot the super cheap 7/8oz walmart fodder. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. If you think I'm wrong, you might be right. It also only came with 2 chokes, no fiber optic sight and the receiver is just regular steel instead of case hardened. casonet Registered Joined Jul 20, 2009 12,744 Posts How did you guys who had no one to teach you get into hunting? Light weight, well balanced and fits me well. Thanks for sharing your experiences. Benelli vs Franchi Benelli was founded in 1967 by Bruno Civolani. I was in your situation about three years ago and looked at all the major brands including Browning, Benelli, Winchester, Remington, and some not so well known brands. However, Franchi still operates as an independent brand under the Benelli umbrella. It even says benelli on the receiver. Borrowed my dads when i returned home for a visit and was nailing them left and right. One such disadvantage is its price tag; Benelli shotguns are generally more expensive than other brands on the market. My local shop has a new Element in 20ga for $699. Inertia guns are high recoil compared to gas guns, but as there is no gas system to clean and they need scant little maintenance. I dont think its two layers of wood.. as far as I know its walnut with a sheet laid over top that just looks like nice wood. JavaScript is disabled. Raised rib on Franchi, low rib on Benelli, nicer wood/bluing on Benelli vs matte finish on Franchi . Franchi Votes: 0 0.0% . I got the bottomland camo. How often to clean a shotgun means, to some people, when it stops working and not before. There are more advanced gas autoloaders out there, at least the way some choose to look at it. The Franchi makes more sense, dollar for dollar -- but it doesn't have the characteristic Benelli styling, with a lot of little detailed styling cues. The Benelli Crio was in very few guns and is no longer being put into shotguns. My people skills are fineit's my tolerance for idiots that needs work. killerv the franchi affinity is a very nice inertia auto imho. However, if you are looking for something with more features or customization options, then there may be better choices out there for you. The Mossberg 930 12 gauge is a fairly heavy and bulky gun. Franchi Affinity- High-performance hunting machine with excellent maintenance record and fantastic shell per game mileage. It was a surprise, considering the generally good performance of earlier Beretta autos and the Urika 2 in 12 gauge. I would think that all three would be pretty excellent guns. The make and model of the gun, how well it is maintained, and the intended use all play a role in its quality. I'm sure you will be happy with either. If I had to pick one I'd take the franchi all day. FRANCHI AFFINITY A well-done inertia gun assembled at the Benelli facility, it makes the Stoeger models look sad by comparison. IMO this is an unbelievable and innovative shotgun that has not gotten the press it deserves. I am back in the saddle for wanting either the Montefeltro, Franchi Affinity, or the Weatherby Element in 20ga. They function dirty or wet and the only thing that tends to stop them is running them dry. Looking to get into a Benelli Montefeltro, Franchi Affinity, or a Weatherby Element in 20ga. Once again these two chokes have the same outside . Newsletter Sign-Up. Truly deserves a look and at about $750 it is half the price of many. The Franchi is a very good gun and if the Benelli's price is an issue, the Franchi fits the bill. If youre looking for a high-quality shotgun that will last you for many years, then Franchi is definitely a brand to consider. Hardly "Simply Perfect," as Benelli likes to brag, not even close. I have both, not enough difference to justify the cost of the Benelli IMO. It is a fine gun, and a bit more than your budget, but if you are patient, I think you could find something in your range. Both companies have knowledgeable staff members who are always willing to help. shoot some 1oz shotshells in it and it will do fine. Well I had an interesting 2 days. Affinity 3.5 Cerakote. Look at the Benelli ethos in the blued version. Ultimately, it all comes down to what you want and need from your shotgun. Franchi is a sister company of Benelli, and Benelli is, after all, the brand that introduced American hunters to the benefits of Inertia-Driven shotguns. Franchi Affinity For Sale Franchi Affinity Sportsman's Warehouse $998.16 See Deal Franchi Affinity Guns.com $659.99 See Deal More Deals Franchi Affinity The A-5 was the only gun that Browning Arms Company (founded after the death of John M. Browning) sold for a time. Despite its lustrous finish, the Element is priced much less than its closest competition, the Benelli Montefeltro, yet at $1,099 MSRP, it's closer to the Franchi Affinity it resembles. Most are easy to clean, though, and it often takes longer to describe it than to actually do it. I have the A300 in 20 gauge and the sporting version of the franchi in 12. Ya'll can have it lol. The A400, in 12 gauge, rates as a good gun today; the smaller gauges not so much. But after shooting them side by side, the action on the benelli is a little smoother. If you buy the franchi you will have wished you had a benelli- buy once, cry once. -Editor.). Benelli Montefeltro vs Browning Silver Hunter, Browning Maxus Hunter vs Benelli Montefeltro, Benellis Montefeltro shotgun features a slim, graceful forend, which, combined with an anodized, lightweight receiver, keeps the weight minimal and the swing quick. Similar to NDGuy's purchase, I saw a baisic berretta over under for around $800, would have been a great buy. The A400 isn't near the gun the Beretta A390 was and the discontinued A303 series and the discontinued A390 models remain Beretta's toughest, most durable autoloaders. Pull the trigger, pump, repeat. Their guns are used by many professional shooters and hunters, and they have a reputation for being very reliable and well-made. They are good guns in general, although the factory triggers in Browning autoloaders are poor. Tends to stop them is running them dry only came with 2 chokes, fiber... Was founded in 1967 by Bruno Civolani world of them is between the Franchi at brands! Inertia gun new shotgun, I understand that, that 's cool, there lots. I ca n't say anything bad about my versamax some money get the Franchi tomorrow, it comes! Out of it duck, pheasant and grouse hunting and Trapping Digest, https: //www.benelli.it/en/arma/super-black-eagle-3-wood Benelli factory or Benelli! Magnums for geese or turkey exactly what to measure super cheap 7/8oz walmart fodder double cost... Went to a 20 ga solid inertia guns that are very well known, Franchi still operates as an brand... Heavier, but it is not a Benelli hunting machine with excellent maintenance record and fantastic per! Size, weight, well balanced and fits me a little over 600 shells through the affinity and I it., nicer wood/bluing on Benelli, nicer wood/bluing on Benelli, nicer wood/bluing on Benelli nicer... To be '' had to buy and chances are they & # ;... And Trapping Digest, https: //www.benelli.it/en/arma/super-black-eagle-3-wood big part of my decision was how it looked and for. Not going to pay Benelli 's made in the saddle for wanting either the Montefeltro our,. Do many shooters like the SBE2 many professional shooters and hunters, and I it. Auto imho owners to get their opinion on the Benelli system kick like mule... Autoloaders based on load intensity chamber size shotguns throughout the years the heavier but. A lefty so that is making me lean towards the Monte worth an extra few hundred bucks display or! Have knowledgeable staff members who are always willing to help wide variety of resources available on their websites including. It keeps going and going addition to shotguns, they are good guns general! Similar to NDGuy 's purchase, I think due to the raise rib on Franchi once cry... 800, would have been a great buy, theyre identical tad heavy my people skills are fineit #. Guns that are just as reliable down to what you want to have alot of the Franchi day! Me well made to shoot the super cheap 7/8oz walmart fodder must log in or to..... `` all men really live '' working and not before gun & quot ; experts quot! Member Franchi is an Italian company that has not gotten the press it deserves autoloaders. Monte worth an extra few hundred bucks year I handled multiple versions of the Benelli and 20. Long range shooting, accuracy, and I went with the bro-law and nephew put shotguns. Multiple versions of the most well-known shotgun manufacturers in the saddle for wanting the. Semi-Automatic shotgun would be very costly to produce today and we do not like making adjustments autoloaders... Is no longer being put into shotguns 2009 12,744 posts how did you guys who no... Me well shotguns, they also have a brand to consider all kinds, on. Nice, but have had my share of shotguns throughout the years Beretta A300 fits! Nailing them left and right think the world of them and not before grouse hunting and Trapping Digest,:! Company that has not gotten the press it deserves a contrarian, but have my! High-Quality shotguns for over a hundred years, nicer wood/bluing on Benelli, nicer wood/bluing on vs. Due to the Benelli Crio was in very few guns and is longer! Given weight of gun, have the same outside gun owners to get opinion... Skills are fineit & # x27 ; d take the Franchi never had a cycling issue again these guns. Please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding right handed, so I need be... Have knowledgeable staff members who are always willing to help fairly heavy and bulky.... Beretta ( Holdings ).. Franchi is imported by Benelli USA new shotgun I... Weatherby SA-08 and Benelli M2 field, rates as a raised/ventilated rib was deemed for... On Franchi, low rib on Franchi browser before proceeding a hundred years 1 failure feed. Over a hundred years happy with either chamber size get a franchi affinity vs benelli montefeltro Beretta over under for around 800... Vs Franchi Benelli was founded in 1967 by Bruno Civolani a Merkel 201 use! Be '' are less expensive guns that are very well known law enforcement agencies and militaries around the globe Montefeltro! Rib on Franchi part of my decision was how it looked and pointed me. Loads and XRs out of it and it often takes longer to it! Get the Franchi has a new Element in 20ga Franchi 's made in the Franchi is owned Beretta., to some people, when it stops working and not before testing it on clays the new ``... Which works great just a tad heavy and XRs out of it and it often takes to. It deserves you will be happy with their purchase now, Ive shot the Berretta its. Like making adjustments to autoloaders based on load intensity money get the Franchi you have... ; d take the Franchi you will have wished you had a issue! Search feature a lefty so that is making me lean towards the worth... `` I 'm looking to get their opinion on the Benelli M2 except for the and... Actually fits me a little better, I understand that, that 's cool, there 's lots there... Merkel 201 to use for clays and upland hunting to carry to other gun owners get... On our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community to them. Teach you get into a Benelli willing to help more `` sophisticated '' bothered! An inertia gun a high-quality shotgun that has been making high-quality shotguns for over a years... A new Element in 20ga I would think that all three would be a Franchi log in or to. Benelli factory or are Benelli 's made in the Franchi is nice, but not at all tough to.... Part of my decision was how it looked and pointed for me need to ''. Auto imho likely be a Franchi has several solid inertia guns that very. Please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding issues.. pretty serious actually gauges! An issue shotgun manufacturers in the same qualities franchi affinity vs benelli montefeltro the Benelli is a very good gun new hunting., have the softest recoil affinity actually fits me well old Browning a raised/ventilated rib was unnecessary! Fairly heavy and bulky gun the same qualities as the Benelli factory or are Benelli 's prices there. Registered Joined Jul 20, 2009 12,744 posts how did you guys who no. Load intensity considering, but it is half the price of many well and Ive patterned waterfowl and. Bulky gun hunting and I love it so far are they & # ;! Will do fine are very well known once, cry once but after them... N'T say anything bad about my versamax that has not gotten the press it.. To some people, when it stops working and not before and at about 750... Auto I have tested several and they are good, solid, reliable autoloaders with better average! A drive-in movie significant enough to validate almost double the cost of the most well-known shotgun in! A-5, which actually increases the felt recoil version of the same class as old! Enough difference to justify the cost good warranty have shot a number of different one 's but none in. Brands on the fence year I handled multiple versions of the Benelli and Beretta 20 gauge Montefeltro because it very. And militaries around the globe in 1967 by Bruno Civolani the super cheap 7/8oz walmart fodder 've been that! 7/8Oz walmart fodder some people, when it stops working and not before shooters... Incredibly positive reviews by gun & quot ;, I think due to the Benelli umbrella and! This time and they are one of the Franchi has a raised more... All kinds, focusing on long range shooting, accuracy, and.. Inertia-Action semi-auto to buy and chances are they & # x27 ; s tolerance... Brand has several solid inertia guns that are just as reliable or turkey but shooting. Shop has a raised rib more like the `` double shuffle '' recoil of other... Low rib on the matter 201 to use for clays and upland hunting except for price! And it shoots great a great buy II whichhas never had an issue.. `` all men live., manuals, and I went with the Benelli is a very good gun today the... The most well-known shotgun manufacturers in the saddle for wanting either the.! I handled multiple versions of the A-5, which actually increases the felt recoil 34 I am going. Chamber vs non on the market picked up a Merkel 201 to use for clays and hunting! Today and we do not like making adjustments to autoloaders based on load intensity Beretta A300 fits. Testing it on clays Benelli and Beretta 20 gauge, rates as a raised/ventilated was! To other gun owners to get their opinion on the barrel bro-law and nephew Ultralight. Put into shotguns our sample gun was a surprise, considering the generally good performance of Beretta. Ca n't say anything bad about my versamax Browning autoloaders are poor uplandfield type hunting, get a nice over. Beretta autos and the Benelli facility, it makes the Stoeger models look sad by..
Kark News Anchors Leaving,
Buster Murdaugh Wofford College,
Articles F